A Comparison Between Dulce Et Decorum Est and Pro Patria Essay

The First universe of discourse War was the first truly young strugglefare. Its atrocities and huge death toll changed masss views of war drastically. professional patria, by Owen gob and Dulce et decorousness est by Wilfred Owen are both war metrical compositions written around the time of the First World War, and as much(prenominal) share certain surface properties. However, the two poems differ hugely in their implicit meaning and intentions, giving the two poems many subtle differences amongst their texts. twain poems usage metaphor. Seaman personas metaphor when work forcetioning the brute sword and sol analyzers development storied scutcheons, a blaringly inaccurate image to conjure up the humor of chivalry and knights in shining armor, giving that the fighting would be plumb and glorious, as opposed to the mass slaughter and unimaginable tortures spelled fall disclose in Owens Dulce et decorum est. seaman also makes wont of anthropomorphisation, making Englan d out as some broad, good but indistinct creature. He refers to England as a being of some sort, writing of its pleas for peace at the nations bar, stating that England needed to go to war to keep its honor. Owen uses metaphor to disposition the state of the soldiers in his poem, saying that the men were drunk with fatigue. The use of simile is more found only in his poem, when he negotiation about soldiers bent double, like beggars under sacks and coughing like hags. The use of simile as opposed to metaphor adds to the realness of the poem.Both war poems have religious undertones. The use of Latin in both texts assist this, mimicking the Latin masses of the Catholic Church. Seaman says that those left at space whilst their sons go to war must be strong in credence and in prayer and that they should ask what offering we may consecrate, suggesting to the people back home to turn to their faith for comfort, and to be willing to flop up the luxuries of a quiet life for the greate r good. Dolce et decorousness est, on the other hand, uses the idea of the devils face to hound the expression of a gas victimHis hanging face, like a Devils dark of sinThe comparison also describes the demesne weariness of the soldier, what atrocities must a devil be to be sick of sin?Both poems are trying to affect the publics views on the war. master Patria is essentially a propaganda poem, an invention used to great effect during the Boer war and revived at the advent of the First World War. The poems early references to honor and duty are to provoke young men into singing up for the army, fabricating images of glorious victory in their minds, and carefully avoiding the nitty gimpy mechanics of it, the living in squalid trenches and the likelihood of death.The later sections of the poem are addressed to the parents of the warrior sons urging them to keep a stiff f number lip, or as he puts it to hush all vulgar din of the street. The reason for this is that if every time a mother standard a letter from the M.O.D telling her that her son was dead she were to rush out into the street screaming OH MY GOD, MY POOR HARRY HES foregone other mothers and fathers would have reservations about sending their sons off to war. Therefore the relieve of bereaved parents of worrier sons went some way to helping the recruiting sergeants job.Dulce et Decorum est is the perfect opposite of the propaganda that is Pro Patria. Whiles Pro Patria uses misleading metaphors Dulce et Decorum est attempts to create the realities of war. Where Pro Patria attempts to glorify war and depict it as honorable, Dulce et Decorum est shows the dirt grime and suffering that went on at the breast line. The stolidness of the soldiers to the gruesome death of the gas victims as they fling him in the drop behind (the use of the word flung emphasizing the fact that this was not unusual and that it had happened before), the commentary of the soldiers as beggars shows a stark contrast to Seamans soaring and noble warrior sons.In structure the poems are quite similar, Dulce et Decorum est faceing to be almost a parody of the older Pro Patria. thus when read line by line alternately from different poems, the poems seem to compliment each otherEngland in this great fight to which you go, readiness double like old beggars under sacksAlso, the last stanzas of both poems use very similar rhyme patterns. Pro Patrias penultimate lines rhyme best with test, and Dulce et Decorum est rhymes zest with est in the same lines (in relation to the end).Both poems encapsulate their message in the last lines, the finishing pleas of Seamen for parents to send their sons to war, and the dear Latin verse of Dulce et Decorum est warning people not to fumble in jingoismMy friend you would not tell with such mettlesome zest,To children,the old lie Dulce et decorum estPro patria mori(How sweet and fitting it is to die for your country)Both poems are from around the time of the Fir st World War, Pro Patria was written just before the outbreak, written during the conflict.I believe that the billet taken by the authors stems from their experience of the war and the time at which they were written. Seaman did not and could not know what was to happen in the Great War, as it was yet to happen when he wrote the poem. Owen, on the other hand, had been at the front line, and had seen what he was writing about, and felt a need to tell others what he had seen, as opposed to Seaman who was writing for the government.